As a business owner, we get it: the more data, the better. Right? It can feel like hoarding your email list is a surefire way to pump more sales into your business. But truth be told, sometimes it's okay to let go. Hanging on to customers who just aren't interested anymore probably costs you more than it's worth, and not only in dollars.
Send to a list that's half unengaged and you've already set yourself up for low deliverability and higher spam complaints. A smaller, active list beats a big, dormant one.
But when the numbers feel so precious, how do you know which emails to cull and which to keep? Here's how we break it down.
Remove soft and hard bounces
Some people sign up with a work or school email. Once they leave or graduate, that address effectively stops existing. Rather than mailing into an empty void, clean out your bounces:
Remove any address that has soft-bounced more than five times. Five strikes and it's out.
Nothing to do here. Klaviyo automatically suppresses hard bounces the moment they happen.
Give customers the chance to unsubscribe
Some customers want to unsubscribe but never find the time. They're actively avoiding your emails while taking up precious room. A sunset flow with a clear "unsubscribe" prompt lets them remove themselves:
Better they choose to leave cleanly than sit dormant and drag your deliverability down.
Suppress unengaged contacts
Every owner dreams of a fully engaged list, but that's not reality. Over time, some customers stop wanting your emails, maybe their purchase was a gift, or they simply no longer need you. They open less and less, until it's been over a year. The key is setting clear parameters for how long you let them wander before you suppress them. But this differs by product:
A monthly food-subscription customer who goes quiet for 180 days is a clear sign of poor engagement. For luxury perfume, that gap might stretch to years and still be normal. Understanding your customer lifespan makes sure you suppress the right audiences, not the wrong ones.
A clean list isn't a smaller list. It's a list that actually wants to hear from you.
Let's get your database clean and healthy.
Never cleaned your database before and not sure where to start? Worried about suppressing the wrong data? We're here to help make your list as clean as can be. Book a free consultation today.
Book a free 15-minute consult